In this episode of Receivables Podcast, host Adam Parks sits down with Erin Snyder from National Creditors Bar Association (NCBA), along with J-T Gaietto and Kyle Simpson, to explore how its Committed to Security (CTS) program is changing the approach to vendor risk management.

Listen to Your Favorite Podcasts

Adam Parks (00:07)

Hello everybody, Adam Parks here with another episode of Receivables Podcast. Today I’m here with a really interesting discussion about how the National Creditors Bar Association, better known as NCBA, has rolled out a vendor management program and the steps they’ve taken to continually improve it.

Not only to help law firms better understand their own cybersecurity posture, but also to help third-party vendors, process servers, and everyone in that law firm ecosystem. So excited to have Erin joining me today, as well as JT and Kyle, each coming from a different perspective. But in order to kick this off, could I have everybody tell me a little about yourself and how you got to the seat that you’re in today?

I’m just gonna go in the order on my screen. So, Erin, starting with you, could you give us a little taste of your background?

Erin Snyder (01:00)

Yeah, sure. Nice to see everyone. I’m Erin Snyder with NCBA. I am the VP of Membership and Partnerships. I’ve had a long career in association work, mostly with members and vendors on year-round partnerships, and a long career in events. Excited to continue this work with our vendors and with our members, especially on the cybersecurity side.

I think this is an important issue that we’re all kind of dealing with these days. And so I’m excited to see how this continues with our members.

Adam Parks (01:34)

Well, in 2025, data security was the number one concern for debt collection operations in the TransUnion Debt Collection Industry Survey. So I think you are right on point with identifying the challenge that folks are facing today. Kyle, moving on to you, could you give us a little bit about your background?

Kyle Simpson (01:52)

Sure, my name is Kyle Simpson. I am the Senior Vice President of Strategic Initiatives at TRAK America. Before joining TRAK earlier this year, I spent over 20 years at large financial services organizations, primarily in the recovery space, managing third-party networks of law firms and collection agencies and driving strategy across those organizations. And that ultimately led me into this position where we are today and talk about the deployment of fourth-party oversight. And third-party oversight from an inf information security standpoint.

Adam Parks (02:22)

Well, I’m looking forward to learning from your perspective today. Sounds like you’ve got a lot of experience to share with us. And JT, could you tell everyone a little about yourself?

JT Gaietto (02:30)

Sure. I’m JT Gaietto. I’m the Chief Operating Officer at Convergent DS. Prior to going into an advisory role, I was the CISO for SquareTwo Financial, where we focused on managing not just debt buying, but also our legal collection network, and I was responsible for developing our vendor due diligence, both third-party and fourth-party risk programs in alignment with the Money Center banks that we worked with.

Adam Parks (02:54)

Fantastic. And so I know you started this program a couple of years ago, Erin, and now you’re going through a modification of the program. Could you tell me a little about the background of this program and what kind of changes you’re undertaking in 2026?

Erin Snyder (03:10)

Yeah, absolutely. So this program really exists. It started out as a subcontractor oversight program. It was a very manual process with our vendors. We weren’t getting much traction just because it was such a manual process. We didn’t have a centralized system. And so we’ve really worked very hard with the Convergent DS team and JT and his team to work through this platform.

We really came up with a streamlined process. Everything happens in the platform, and it’s a much more professional and, again, streamlined process to work on these assessments with our members and with our vendors. You know, we’re all seeing a steady increase in these cyber attacks. Cyber risk is shared across the ecosystem. It’s a serious challenge that requires a lot of visibility and consistency. And so this is something that we’re really, we want to see the due diligence with our members and keep this top of mind.

Adam Parks (04:10)

Interesting. Are you seeing that organizations are learning more about themselves as they’re going through these assessments? Meaning, like, as they’re going from that kind of pen-and-paper version of it to this more digital format, are you seeing an acceleration of that self-awareness in learning?

Erin Snyder (04:29)

Definitely, you know, this program was kind of started as it was meant to be for the vendors to go through their own self-assessment. But we’re actually seeing more of our law firm members choose to do this themselves, you know, as their own kind of self-assessment to get ready. Maybe they’re getting ready for, you know, their first SOC 2 kind of cyber risk readiness, compliance readiness. 

And again, it’s, you know, most law firms aren’t ready or aren’t built to kind of manage these in-depth reviews of these controls. And again, redundancy for the vendors having to kind of go through all those questionnaires over and over again. This was a great solution for vendors and law firms, so they don’t have to go through the same questionnaire over and over again. They can do it once and share it widely with their clients.

Adam Parks (05:19)

So JT, from your perspective, how has the experience of the participant changed? Those who are being audited, you know, how long was it taking them? How long is it taking them now? And what tools and support are being provided to assist them, especially through that first journey through the process?

JT Gaietto (05:39)

Great question, Adam. And so, you know, I’ve got, I guess, the unique perspective of what it was like before, when everything was very manual, right? Where you’d send out a set of controls, you’d get some form of questions back, you’d get some attachments with that, and you’d have a very nuanced but repetitive back-and-forth with the vendor. And it wasn’t necessarily the person you were dealing with’s top priority because they had a day job.

So, knowing that going through some of those assessments, especially for your high-risk and critical vendors on an annual basis, could take, you know, six to ten weeks. And it was very onerous, right? And very manual for the vendor, but also manual for the person doing the assessment. Fast forward to what we’ve been able to accomplish with CTS, we’ve developed a piece of proprietary software that, you know, if anybody’s playing Buzzword Bingo, it is AI-augmented.

But what, you know, the AI allows us to do is remove a lot of the stare and compare work that a traditional human would have had to do. And so, you know, taking policies, procedures, and work guidelines, the AI ingests that and then maps that to the CTS control framework. And then a human assessor looks at that. And so what the AI is able to do, and just to use a very simple example, is: do you perform call recording when making calls?

You know, if that call procedure is there, it maps that to that control. And the system will actually say the likelihood and percentage that this meets the mark based on the implementation guidance. So then the human can dig in and say, yeah, 85% of this meets the intent, or 35% is that there. And then that allows them to send a follow-up to the vendor and say, Can you provide some more detail on this? Or they get on a phone call and have that dialogue, but it cuts the time down to do the assessment dramatically, and so on.

When we’re asked by vendors coming through the program or law firms, they say, well, you know, how many weeks do you think this will take? And I said, really, it’s dependent on you, like how fast you can provide the data to us. Greenfield, if you get everything loaded in the system, it’s less than 2 weeks. But for some folks, because again, it’s not their day job, it takes a little bit longer, but you know, we can move at a pace that’s unforeseen previously, just because of how much the AI augmentation helps us move through it.

Adam Parks (07:51)

Well, when you talk about the human resource, is that human resource on your team or the vendor’s team? Or the assessor?

JT Gaietto (07:57)

Great question. A shared res, yeah, it’s a shared responsibility, right? The assessor is on our team, and they’re qualified assessors, meaning that they’ve got financial services experience. They hold a credential like a CISSP or a CISM. So you know, we do a tremendous number of assessments per year across multiple industries. 

And then the other human element of that is whoever’s responding to these various requests. It’s impactful on both sides, and we’ve been able to make that much more efficient.

Adam Parks (08:26)

And Kyle, as somebody who’s placing accounts and managing the process with these laws between kinds of creditors and the law firms, what has your experience been as this technology has been implemented into the process?

Kyle Simpson (08:41)

Our experience is relatively new, but what we’ve seen so far is an interesting adoption, similar to what Erin pointed out. We rolled out a requirement for the fourth parties to us, third parties to our law firms and collection agencies, to go through, and then started to see interest at the firm and agency level as well, recognizing that they too would be the subject of information security assessments, whether they be from TRAK or ourselves.

Other clients, our TRAK America’s direct clients in addition to those, and that there was a benefit to be had to them going through the assessment directly. Also seeing and hearing the conversation around the benefit of centralizing that assessment into one location for, let’s say, a process server provider. They do one assessment rather than X number of assessments across their client base, and each one being different.

So being able to kind of knock out all of those requirements with one assessment rather than with, you know, 20 or however many clients are coming after them for the same sort of information. And then also seeing the reduction in effort required to push those assessments out to their clients, being able to either push or give access to the portal and being able to provide the report in one fashion rather than having 10 people come. Searching for the same sort of information.

Adam Parks (10:03)

So one of the things that I hear in all of that is that there’s an opportunity to reduce the costs associated with compliance and potentially even insurance on behalf of those organizations that are being audited. Because now I start thinking about it as I’m going through my own cyber liability policy renewal season, right? As we’re heading into the end of the year, I start thinking about how much better an organization can answer those questions to reduce that.

And whether or not the same level of compliance team is necessary in order to conduct those activities on an annual basis. If you’re going from 20 audits a year to one audit a year, how those resources could be better allocated throughout the law firm or the vendor’s organization. Have you heard anybody who’s gone through the program start talking about it?

The ultimate savings, because I’m sure there’s a cost to going through it. There’s a cost to the human resource time and all of that. But it sounds like there’s potentially a pretty significant financial opportunity here as well. What have you heard as organizations have started going through this process?

That’s right. I’m floating that one out to the whole group.

JT Gaietto (11:12)

I’ll start. I mean, I know since we started the program, when we started working with the NCBA, this isn’t the first industry vertical we’ve been doing a program similar to this with. So we went through a structured rollout, we did a beta period, and now that we’ve opened the program up to everybody, a couple of things have stood out. One, most people do talk about the ease of getting through the process and consuming the data post-process.

 

Where there’s still some ground to be made, right, is getting the consumers of that data, you know, to be able to feel comfortable with the content, how that content was derived, and that the follow-up material behind that is done on a timely basis. And that just takes time, right? And if you think about the old model, if you went through an assessment and you had remediation items, it was my personal experience with the 63 vendors we had in our pool at SquareTwo: you’d go see them in 2025 and say, hey, here are the five things we need you to go improve on. You go see them in 2026, you’re like, here are the six things, and five of these from last year, right? And it was kind of the rinse, wash, repeat process.

This adds accountability now, where you can actually track the remediation through the portal and the various stakeholders they share it with.

That information with. For instance, Kyle’s team can say, Yeah, I see that’s a medium risk. For us, that’s really important. They can actually say, This is highly critical for us. And that gives the vendor direction on saying, okay, yeah, I’ve got five things to do, but if I want to keep working with Kyle, I gotta take care of the one that would have been at the bottom of the list and put that at the top. 

And then they’re held accountable too for following up and answering those questions. And so yeah, you’re right. There’s definitely a cost improvement and opportunity there, but it’s kind of priming that pump to get to where we want to be and getting everybody in the supply chain comfortable with the fact that, you know, how are we gathering the evidence, but then how do we follow up on those actions after the fact.

Adam Parks (13:14)

Kyle, what kind of feedback have you heard from your vendors or the third-party vendors as organizations have started going through this? You know, what kind of benefits are they seeing from the process beyond the consolidation into a single audit?

Kyle Simpson (13:30)

So it’s still early for us. So we haven’t completely wrapped up all of the assessments through our suppliers’ fourth parties. So the feedback that we’ve heard so far has been pretty limited. And again, because these are fourth parties to us, we’re not going to hear that feedback directly. It’s going to go to our suppliers, our law firms, and agencies first rather than to us. So it’s going to kind of telephone back to us if you think about the telephone game. And I don’t think we’re there yet to be able to share all of the feedback from those fourth parties.

Adam Parks (14:03)

Sure, my curiosity is mostly around the insurance piece too, because I would think that by answering those questions in a more robust format, or items that are identified as they’re going through the audit process, the lack of two-factor authentication on platform A or B, whatever the case may be, is potentially providing them with a lower overall premium because they now have things in place that they may not have had previously.

I don’t know a lot of organizations that look at an insurance application and say, okay, here’s the checklist of things that I need to address, right? As they complete it, they push it out, and they move on. But as that cost continues to rise and we think about the volume of records and the level of security necessary for each one of our independent systems, it seems like more of a um more of an opportunity. 

You know, for an organization that’s beginning this journey from step one, they’re working with NCBA organizations, and they want to start going through this process. What does that look like? Right. I know you can get it down to 2 weeks, but from a realistic standpoint, right? Let’s assume that it’s an average organization. What does that really look like in terms of the first steps in a journey of a thousand miles?

JT Gaietto (15:15)

Yeah, that’s a great question. And the first thing that whoever they interact with on our side says to them is, “Look, this is absolutely a journey.” You’re gonna see things in this assessment that you may not already have. Maybe you don’t have a work-from-home policy; maybe you don’t have specific documentation on how to handle multifactor authentication, you know, as you mentioned, Adam. Don’t run off and create it right now.

Like, let’s go through and assess where you’re at today because it’s the coaching after the fact that’s going to be more valuable to you. Then you run off, maybe download a bunch of stuff off the internet, feed it in. It still doesn’t meet the mark. So then you get findings, and it just creates extra work for you. 

Adam Parks (15:55)

Create new problems.

JT Gaietto (15:57)

So it’s exactly that. And so we typically try to coach them and say, come as you are, there’s no right or wrong answer. We’re really trying to assess where you stand today and then give you recommendations and guidance on how to go from point A to point B. That’s probably the part that I think a lot of folks aren’t used to. Some of the things, some of the assessments I’ve set, personally, with various different vendor types, they’ve said, ” Well, we’ve never been asked that before. Why does that matter? And we’re like, well, and then you kind of coach them on why this is important. This might be why you hadn’t been asked that before.

And a lot of times they do get a little cautious about that. And they’re like, look, this is for someone like Kyle or another consumer of these reports to make a risk-based decision. You know, and the way I like to coach is, think of a process server. There are obviously several national providers of process serving across the US, but there are certain regions, certain counties in certain demographic areas that those national providers don’t service.

And there’s just not a lot of consumers in that market. And so maybe, you know, a law firm might only service something there twice a year, right? So if they go out to that small mom- and -pop process server and they don’t look like one of the big national guys, they can make a risk-based decision and say, Well, it’s 2 records; it’s not 20,000 records. Here’s really what we need to do. And that’s the way we typically coach some of those guys through. It’s like, look, you don’t have to look like the big guys.

We, you know, you just need to think about the size and complexity of what you do in your day-to-day business. And that allows someone to make a business-based decision on how much risk they’re willing to take. And that really does help people wrap their head around the thought process in which this program was created.

Adam Parks (17:45)

Well, let’s go a little bit deeper down that coaching path because I think that’s really interesting, right? So is this procedure or the process that an organization is going through at least somewhat different than going through a SOC 2, right? Because the SOC 2 is like, ” Here’s the finding. But it sounds like you’re going through maybe a pre-assessment and some coaching to help provide them with some resources, education, and/or maybe direction on tools that could be deployed in order to solve the problem. So this is more of a group effort at cybersecurity across an industry.

JT Gaietto (18:20)

Yeah, it’s like that old adage, right? As the saying goes, “all boats rise with the tide,” right? And I think it’s a great juxtaposition between the SOC 2. So this isn’t, and you know, we don’t hold it out to be as rigid as a SOC 2 Type 2, where they’re like, okay, hey, I wanna see every background check you’ve done for the last 12 months, and then they take a random sample size and of that.

Do we ask if they’re doing background checks? Yep. Do we ask for evidence of what that looks like, and is it multi-state and does it meet the mark? Absolutely. But we’re not going, you know, that far in depth on saying, ” Show me everyone you’ve done over the year and then taking a 10% or 15% sample of it. The other half of where the AI augmentation helps: we’ve trained the system on about 50,000 different assessment feedback items, both from assessments we’ve done, but also from the open-source security control framework, or the SCF. 

And so when there’s a finding, again, we’ll pick one of the really easy ones, about multi-factor authentication for remote access; the system will actually give the assessor recommendation guidelines to provide back to the client on, hey, I know that based on what you fed me, they’re using Office 365 and they’ve got a VPN and they’ve got this.

Here are some areas they might want to focus on for how to implement that. So they’re getting that feedback from the engagement. And then, as they do that remediation, another, you know, and they provide evidence that they’ve done that work, the humans on our side look at that and say, yeah, that meets the mark, or, you know, hey, you’re almost there, you might think about doing this. So it is very much a journey where, again, if you look at the SOC 2 Type 2, not only do they do those sample-size body checks, if you’ve got a finding or a deficiency.

That’s there for the year, right? That doesn’t change until you go through the next audit cycle. Whereas this, once the remediation is accepted, the system updates that. And then your categorical risk score that’s been, you know, applied, that is also dynamic, right? So as you’re moving and maturing, you know, assessment to assessment, you know, your risk score is changing in the system.

Adam Parks (20:30)

Well, especially for smaller organizations that are going through their own growth process and establishing themselves, whether they’re expanding or whatever the case may be, it sounds like the coaching provides a real opportunity not only for those that need to be conducting the assessments, but for those that are being assessed as well. From a legal perspective, from a law firm’s perspective.

I mean, it sounds like you’ve had a pretty high engagement rate from the law firms looking to get their service providers in alignment with these standards. You know, has there been a time period that the law firms are giving? You know, what’s the speed at which all of this is happening across the ecosystem?

JT Gaietto (21:18)

Yeah, I’d let Erin answer some of that as well. I’d say from our perspective, what we’ve seen, the law firms that we’ve interacted with, they’re just overwhelmed with the fact that they’ve got to do third-party due diligence, right? A lot of these firms just don’t have a dedicated vendor manager, right? It’s one hat of many that someone on that team wears. A recent conversation I had with a law firm, you know, the gentleman got on the phone. He says, Look, I’ve got 86 vendors that I’ve got to look at every year. 

And he’s like, I’m 10 months down the road, and I haven’t looked at a single one of them. I just haven’t had time. And so the initial thing, he’s like, well, I see this swath of vendors have already gone through CTS. How do I get, you know, how do I encourage these other vendors, or how do I handle, you know, he was not only looking to go through for his firm, but he was trying to get some coaching on.

What’s the easiest way for me to slice and dice this? Because it’s so impactful to his day job as a small practitioner. And we hear that story consistently where there’s a body of work that someone’s got to churn through every year for compliance. But this gives them the opportunity to share that burden, right, with the vendor, and not have to rinse and repeat that. And the vendor doesn’t have to go through that consistently.

But because of that dynamic scoring, as we continue to prime that pump, it gives those law firms continuous monitoring that goes beyond what we call today: the traditional point-in-time view. So I do think, you know, over the next 12 to 14 months, we’ll see even more law firms kind of come to that realization, like, geez, I could change what I’m doing with spreadsheets and emails. 

Not only look at what I’m doing for my own program, but go through this assessment just to see where I’m at. And the law firms that have gone through it, again, from what I’ve seen, are actually quite surprised that they may or may not be as good on the cyber protections as they thought.

And you’ve probably seen the news articles recently where there are now threat actors that specifically target law firms, and law firms only, and then, you know, if the law firms don’t play ball, they send physical people to their location to start stealing physical paperwork and files, right? So these guys are serious about what they’re trying to do. 

And I think, you know, law firms would have traditionally thought, yeah, yeah, cyber’s important, but why is someone gonna go after us? A lot of the stuff that we have is public record or whatnot. Now they’re coming to this realization: it’s not necessarily about the content, but if I could shut you down, regardless of what kind of law you practice, how much is that worth to you? Right. And that’s really more the conversation. Yeah.

Adam Parks (23:55)

As somebody who manages over a hundred and fifty websites in the debt collection space, I assure you law firms are being attacked every single day. I’m sure if I turned the camera to the right here, you can see how many attacks we have defended since I’ve been on this call. So I know that it’s happening. I know that they’re a target. Now, Kyle, from your perspective, what’s the most important aspect of this type of program for the vendors that you’re managing and the vendors that they’re managing? Right. Is it that waterfall? Is it, yeah, what piece is most important to you?

Kyle Simpson (24:29)

The piece that’s most important to us is the risk reduction. As JT mentioned, for a long time it felt like the ARM industry was kind of a side target for these threat actors. And that’s changed. I mean, today this threat is real. It’s not just that somebody may happen to target a law firm or a collection agency; they’re going directly after them. 

And we realize that the ecosystem within the arm industry has become exponentially more complex over the last 15 years. You’ve got data availability at a level that it didn’t; it was not, and has never previously been. You have a number of niche partners who law firms, creditors, collection agencies- all of us connect with on a regular basis for needed and necessary services. 

And that just grows the ecosystem as a whole. And we know that the threat and risk isn’t just a possibility; it’s something we have to actively deal with. And it’s not only a risk to us as organizations, but there’s also definitely a financial element to it. Adam, you mentioned the insurance component, which is a real consideration, but then there’s also the loss of revenue from clients by not being able to protect data, whether client data or consumer data. And there’s also ultimately the customer risk. And we need to do everything we can to reduce the risk for both our clients and our consumers so their data and information aren’t exposed.

Adam Parks (25:53)

That makes a lot of sense. And I think the consolidation of all of that is mission-critical. So I really do appreciate the insights you guys have been sharing with me today. Going into our final minutes, any final message that you would speak to the law firm, to their vendors, and to those who should be either respecting the audits or assessments or going through those assessments? And I’ll kind of open that to all of you. ‘Cause I think each of you is coming from a very different perspective.

JT Gaietto (26:23)

Yeah, I’ll step in first and pass the baton. I mean, I think the three things that I think are really important for people to remember are that it is a journey. This is not a computer-says-yes, computer-says-no environment, right? And again, not to disclose dates on when this gets aired, but obviously recently we’ve seen how AI is speeding up some of these issues for organizations.

And I think it’s really important for folks to realize that the patterns and the issues we saw even a year ago have exponentially expanded, and the time in which you can be impacted has really sped up. And so those are probably the two things I really want to encourage folks: that it’s always gonna be something that you’ve got to pay attention to, but unlike the past, even in the near history.

You have to be really laser-focused on this because it’s changing so rapidly. And regardless of who you’re working with, it is a very important thing to keep top of mind.

Adam Parks (27:24)

I think those are some great insights. Go ahead, Kyle.

Kyle Simpson (27:28)

Thanks, Adam. You know, I just want to kind of go back to some of the comments that have been made up until this point and coalesce them into what to consider if I’m in the position of a law firm or a collection agency today. And the first is that we’ve all seen instances across the ARM industry where exposure to consumer data, whether that’s leakage or an active breach, has resulted in the loss of clients at a in a on a low impact level. 

And you know, when we take that even further, we’ve probably all seen instances where that’s been shut down in business for certain organizations by either burying their head in the sand and not treating this as an active threat and risk that needs to be mitigated, or not dealing with it in an adequate way once it happens. And I think what we have here is an opportunity for somebody to engage through CTS, through NCBA and Convergent DS as a mitigator to help reduce that exposure to their third parties.

And continue to think about the data that they’re providing to a process server, an asset vendor, whoever that data is going out to outside of the walls of a collection law firm, and ensuring that we need to provide the data that we’re providing. Do we need to provide the level of data that we’re providing? Do we have destruction policies in place? And then ultimately, what’s the information and risk exposure that’s deemed through an assessment like committed to security?

Adam Parks (28:53)

Love that. I think a lot of really great insights. And Erin, as someone who’s been managing these programs in other places, any final encouragement for our audience for their participation?

Erin Snyder (29:04)

Yeah, I’ll say, coming from, you know, the NCBA perspective, I’m hearing a consistent message here across the board that we want everyone to be proactive here. This solution was built with our industry in mind. We wanna relay the message that members should consider sharing the CTS program with their vendors to help strengthen the security of the broader ecosystem and the supply chain.

Adam Parks (29:29)

All really great insights. I appreciate y’all coming on today, sharing your insights with me. I’ve learned a lot about the program. I’m very excited to see more organizations going through it. I think consolidating these types of programs and having one standard makes it a lot easier for us to execute. And I think, as JT said earlier, it’s going to help all of the ships rise with the tide. And I think that is a mission-critical thing.

This has happened in the world of artificial intelligence, and the threats around us are increasing even faster than our ability to use and deploy these types of tools across our organizations. So thank you, guys, so much for coming on and joining me today. I really appreciate you sharing all of your insights, and I look forward to learning more from you in the near future.

JT Gaietto (30:18)

Likewise, thanks for having us.

Erin Snyder (30:20)

Thank you.

Kyle Simpson (30:21)

Thanks, Adam.

Adam Parks (30:23)

Also, for those of you watching, if you have additional questions you’d like to ask, you can leave them in the comments on LinkedIn and YouTube, and we’ll respond. Or if you have additional topics you’d like to see us discuss, you can leave those in the comments below as well. And hopefully I can get this group back at least one more time to help me keep creating great content for a great industry. But until next time, thank you, everybody, for your time and attention. We’ll see y’all again soon. Bye, everyone.

 

Vendor Risk Management: How NCBA Is Rethinking Cybersecurity

A law firm may have excellent cybersecurity practices, but the same cannot always be said about every vendor handling its consumer data. This uncertainty is becoming one of the biggest challenges in vendor risk management across the receivables industry.

In this Receivables Podcast episode, host Adam Parks welcomes Erin Snyder from the National Creditors Bar Association (NCBA), along with Kyle Simpson and J-T Gaietto, to explore how the Committed to Security (CTS) program helps organizations meet rising creditor demands for verified security (like SOC 2 or CTS). 

Designed as a trusted, cost-effective solution for law firms, vendors, and clients, CTS replaces repetitive reviews with a single annual assessment. The conversation focuses on how the program reduces compliance efforts while strengthening security across the supply chain.

When Vendor Security Assessments Become the Problem

Consider a process-serving company working with 20 different law firms. Each client requests a cybersecurity questionnaire or evidence of security controls. Although the requirements may overlap, the formats and documentation requests often differ.

The vendor spends considerable time responding to similar questions, while law firms independently review information that another organization may have already evaluated. This leads to a process that consumes resources without necessarily improving the quality of oversight.

Erin Snyder explains that NCBA’s original subcontractor oversight initiative encountered similar difficulties. The program initially relied on manual processes without a centralized system, making participation and coordination more challenging. 

The transition to a digital platform created an opportunity to standardize assessments, organize supporting documentation, and simplify how information is shared. Instead of treating every vendor review as a separate exercise, participating organizations can work from a more consistent assessment framework.

Some law firms are participating in assessments themselves, particularly as they prepare for broader cybersecurity compliance requirements. In this context, the assessment process becomes an opportunity to understand existing weaknesses and establish a more informed approach to improvement.

How AI is Changing Third-Party Cybersecurity Assessments

Cybersecurity assessments have traditionally required substantial manual effort. The hurdle is especially acute for collection law firms, which must prove responsible oversight of service providers handling sensitive data, often without a dedicated vendor management team.

J-T Gaietto explains that traditional assessments of critical vendors could previously take six to ten weeks. 

Through AI-assisted documentation analysis and human review, the CTS process can significantly reduce that timeline, with assessments potentially completed in less than two weeks when participants provide the necessary information promptly. The technology identifies relevant evidence and maps it to security controls, eliminating repetitive analysis so qualified professionals can focus on complex evaluations.

As Gaietto explains: “The AI allows us to remove a lot of the stare and compare work that a traditional human would have had to do.”

The distinction between automation and professional judgment is essential. AI can accelerate evidence reviews and highlight potential gaps, but qualified assessors remain responsible for interpreting findings and determining whether the documentation satisfies relevant requirements. 

That combination offers a practical direction for third-party cybersecurity, using technology to improve efficiency without removing the expertise required to make informed decisions. 

Why Cybersecurity Compliance Cannot End with an Assessment

Completing a cybersecurity assessment is an important milestone, but it does not automatically make an organization more secure. 

If a vendor’s assessment identifies inadequate multifactor authentication procedures, the finding may be documented, communicated, and included in a final report, yet the underlying vulnerability remains until corrective action occurs. If the issue is revisited only during the next annual review, the organization may continue operating with a known weakness for months.

This is where NCBA’s approach introduces a meaningful difference. Gaietto describes how the CTS program supports ongoing remediation, allowing vendors to submit evidence of improvements for review by qualified assessors. 

Once the remediation is accepted, the platform can update the relevant risk scores without preserving outdated findings until another assessment cycle. This creates a more current understanding of an organization’s cybersecurity posture and makes progress easier for stakeholders to evaluate.

Continuous remediation also introduces greater accountability by connecting security findings with specific corrective actions. Over time, the approach can help organizations prioritize meaningful improvements and avoid treating annual assessments as isolated administrative exercises.

Fourth-Party Risk Management: Looking Beyond Direct Vendors

The receivables industry relies on an extensive network of specialized service providers, including process servers, technology companies, asset investigation firms, and other operational partners. Many of these organizations depend on subcontractors to deliver their services. 

As a result, sensitive consumer information may travel beyond the original vendor relationship, creating additional exposure that is not always visible to the creditor or collection law firm responsible for the account.

This challenge makes fourth-party risk management highly relevant. Organizations must consider the potential risks introduced by downstream providers. 

Kyle Simpson emphasizes that the ultimate objective of cybersecurity oversight is risk reduction, particularly as the receivables ecosystem becomes more interconnected. His perspective shifts attention from the number of completed assessments toward the practical consequences of inadequate data protection.

Why Risk-Based Vendor Security Assessments Matter

Not every service provider presents the same level of cybersecurity risk. 

A national company processing thousands of consumer records operates under different conditions from a small local process server handling occasional assignments. Applying identical expectations to both organizations may introduce unnecessary complexity without necessarily improving security outcomes. A more proportionate assessment considers the nature of the services provided, the volume and sensitivity of information involved, and the organization’s operational capabilities.

The Committed to Security program goes beyond simply looking good on paper. It’s about uncovering real security gaps and addressing them with practical solutions. 

With this initiative, NCBA is challenging creditors, law firms, and collection agencies to look past static checklists and focus on the underlying vulnerabilities they are meant to expose. After all, a small service provider and a national vendor face different risks, so why should their cybersecurity requirements look identical?

Catch the full discussion with Kyle Simpson, Erin Snyder, and J-T Gaietto on the Receivables Podcast, and visit NCBA’s Committed to Security program for more details.

Key Moments from the Episode

00:07 – Introduction to NCBA and vendor risk management
03:10 – How NCBA’s vendor oversight program evolved
08:41 – Reducing repetitive vendor audits
15:15 – Getting started with cybersecurity assessments
18:20 – How CTS differs from SOC 2 assessments
24:29 – Managing cybersecurity risks across vendor networks
26:23 – Final insights on vendor security and risk reduction

FAQs on Vendor Risk Management

Q1: Why is vendor risk management important for law firms?
A1: Vendor risk management helps law firms identify and address cybersecurity exposure across third-party service providers. Kyle Simpson, Erin Snyder, and J-T Gaietto discuss how NCBA’s Committed to Security program supports standardized assessments and ongoing risk oversight.

Q2: How does NCBA improve third-party cybersecurity assessments?
A2: Through NCBA’s CTS program, vendors can complete standardized assessments, share results with multiple clients, and track remediation. The guests also explain how AI-assisted analysis and human review can make the process more efficient.

Q3: Can AI replace human judgment in vendor risk management?
A3: No. AI can streamline documentation reviews and control mapping, but vendor risk management still requires qualified assessors to evaluate evidence, interpret findings, and guide remediation.

About Company

NCBA logo 400x400 1

National Creditors Bar Association (NCBA)

The National Creditors Bar Association (NCBA) is a professional trade association representing creditors’ rights attorneys and law firms across the United States. Through advocacy, education, professional development, and industry collaboration, NCBA supports the legal collections community while advancing ethical practices, regulatory compliance, and responsible debt collection.

About The Guest

Erin Snyder 400x400 1

Erin Snyder

Erin Snyder is the Vice President of Membership and Partnerships at the National Creditors Bar Association (NCBA), bringing 18 years of experience in project management, event strategy, relationship building, and industry collaboration.

J T Gaietto 400x400 1

J-T Gaietto

J-T Gaietto is the Chief Operating Officer at Convergent DS and a cybersecurity executive with extensive experience in information security, third-party risk management, cybersecurity assessments, and organizational security leadership.

Kyle Simpson 400x400 1

Kyle Simpson

Kyle Simpson is the Senior Vice President of Strategic Initiatives at TRAKAmerica, bringing over 20 years of experience in financial services, recovery operations, third-party vendor management, and strategic initiatives.

Related Roundtable Videos

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!